Wednesday, October 27, 2004

Captain Bringdown

The achievements of Burt Rutan and his team are certainly heady stuff even for the casual space buff. But there are dangers ahead and not all of them involve crashed aircraft. The Powers That Be will not be made fools of nor will they be topped. If Rutan and/or others continue with successful flights, TPTB will be moved to stop them. This could easily be done. The most likely way would be through regulation or legislation. Perhaps there will be an accident involving property damage, injury or even death (God forbid!). The government (whose job it is, after all, to protect us... a little libertarian sarcasm there), will step in and with the help of many "experts" will say, "You see, space travel is complicated and dangerous. So in order to protect you from yourselves, we will pass this legislation that will require certain safety equipment, procedures, etc., etc." And that will be the end of private space. This is even more likely, it seems to me, as people with the stature of Rutan make more and more public, "in your face" critical remarks pointed at government projects. Not that I would want him to stop, of course.

I write all these things as someone on the outside looking in. Yet someone who has studied a bit of history and has had, at least, a bit of a peek inside the workings of the Halls of Power. Of course, there is a simpler, perhaps more likely scenario: an economic collapse. That would put the kabosh on the whole project for sure.

I remember at Starstruck and AMROC we used to say that our major problems were not technical, we could usually figure out a way to do what we needed to do. Our problems were always economic. Now, Rutan seems to have conquered both technical and economic problems so the only thing left are political problems. THEY could turn out to be the brick wall. I sure hope I am wrong.

2 comments:

Backwoods said...

Now Paul, you're beginning to sound as cynical and paranoid as me! :-) But TPTB didn't outlaw FedEx and UPS just because they made the government postal system look like it was still using the Pony Express. Arguably, the post office actually competed with the private folks and offers better service today than it did before it had competition.

I do agree that the regulatory issues regarding private space are critical and probably as important as technical or financial issues ... but that's why what Jim and Courtney have done is so important. And ... they'll still be around to fight the good fight if the issue comes to a head. (Uh, right Jim and Courtney? :-)

Paul said...

Thanks guys, I needed that!